Optimizing Metal Lids for Wide-Mouth Glass Jars in Fatty Food Packaging - China Glass Packaging

1. How to Prevent Leakage in Mason Jar Hazelnut Butter?

Hazelnut butter leaks for three main reasons: the oil separates and gets thin, the lid doesn’t seal properly, or temperature changes create pressure that pushes the lid open.

Here’s how to fix it systematically:

Step 1: Stop Oil Separation (Make It Stable)

The key is to make a smooth, well-blended butter where the oil doesn’t separate.

Blend Well: Use a powerful blender or food processor to grind the nuts until they release their oils and become very smooth.
Add a Natural Stabilizer: Stir in a small teaspoon of lecithin (from soy or sunflower) or a bit of melted coconut oil or cocoa butter. These help bind the oil and solids together, especially when cool.
Fill Correctly:
- Fill While Warm: If your butter is still warm from blending, put it in the jar immediately. As it cools, it creates a slight vacuum that helps the seal.
- Leave Space: Don’t fill the jar to the very top. Leave about 1-1.5 cm of empty space at the top for expansion.
- Wipe the Rim: Clean the jar’s rim and threads perfectly before putting the lid on. Any food bits will break the seal.

Step 2: Get a Perfect Seal

Check the Sealing Ring: Make sure the rubber/silicone ring in the lid is soft, not cracked, and sitting flat.
Use “Hot Fill & Seal”: For best results, fill hot butter into a clean, warm jar. Wipe the rim, screw the lid on tightly, and turn the jar upside down for 5-10 minutes. The heat helps create a vacuum as it cools.
Screw Lid Correctly: Tighten the lid firmly, then loosen it by just a tiny quarter-turn. This gives pressure from inside a little room to escape without breaking the seal.

Step 3: Store It Right

Keep it Cool & Stable: Store sealed jars in a cool, dark cupboard. Avoid places with big temperature swings (like next to the oven or on the fridge door).
Refrigerate After Opening: Once opened, homemade nut butter must go in the fridge. The cold thickens the oils and prevents separation.
Store Upright: Always keep the jar standing up.

Extra Tips for Travel:
For picnics or gifts, add extra protection:

Put a piece of plastic wrap or special sealing film (like Parafilm) over the jar mouth before screwing on the lid.
Wrap some tape around the seam of the lid and jar to prevent it from loosening.
Place the whole jar inside a sealable plastic bag to catch any leaks.

2. What's the Best Lid for Oily Products (Like Nut Butter) in Glass Jars?

For oily products that need to stay fresh and not leak, the standard Mason jar lid (with a flat disk and screw band) is not the best choice.

Top Recommendation: The Press-On Twist-Off Lid
This is the gold standard used for store-bought jams, sauces, and nut butters.

How It Works: The jar is filled hot. As the product cools, it shrinks and creates a vacuum inside. This vacuum powerfully “sucks” the lid’s special, multi-layered seal onto the jar rim.
Why It’s Great:
- Amazing Seal: The seal is designed to block air and oil.
- Vacuum Indicator: The lid has a “safety button” in the center. If it’s popped up, the seal is broken.
- Long Shelf Life: Perfect for products that need to last a year or more.
The Catch: It usually needs a machine to seal properly and is for one-time use.

3. Is a Press-On Twist-Off Lid the Same as a "Claw-Type" Lid?

Yes, they are the same thing.
The “Press-On Twist-Off” lid is the technical name. Because it has lugs (or “claws”) underneath that lock onto the jar, it’s commonly called a “claw-type” twist-off lid or a “four/six-lug” lid.

4. & 5. Why is a Claw-Type Lid Better Than a Standard Mason Jar Lid?

Even if you improve the Mason jar lid with a better gasket, the claw-type lid is superior due to its sealing physics.

Feature	Claw-Type Twist-Off Lid	Standard Mason Jar Lid
Main Sealing Force	Atmospheric Pressure. The vacuum inside + air pressure outside create a powerful, constant force pushing the lid down.	Your Hand Strength. It relies solely on how tightly you screwed the band, which weakens over time.
How It Seals	Full Surface Suction. The vacuum pulls the entire seal flat against the jar rim, leaving no gaps.	Line Compression. It only squeezes a thin ring of the seal against the rim, which can be uneven.
Handles Pressure Changes	Flexible. If the jar warms up, the lid can flex slightly to release pressure without breaking the seal.	Rigid. Pressure from inside pushes directly on the lid, which can warp the seal or loosen the band permanently.
Seal Indicator	Yes. The “pop” sound and safety button tell you if it’s sealed.	No. You can’t easily tell if the seal is still good.

Simple Analogy:

Claw-Type Lid: Like a suction cup stuck to a window. The outside air pressure holds it firmly in place.
Mason Jar Lid: Like a lunchbox with a rubber seal. You rely on the clips or latches (the screw band) to press the seal down, and it can loosen.

6. Why is it Still Better When You Seal Both By Hand?

Because the design of the claw-type lid turns your hand force into a vacuum.

Claw-Type Lid Process: You press down and twist to lock it mechanically in its lowest position. When the hot contents cool and shrink, they create a vacuum automatically. The seal is then maintained by air pressure, not your initial tightening force.
Mason Jar Lid Process: You just screw it down to squish the gasket. All the sealing power comes from the gasket trying to spring back, which fades. It doesn’t create a vacuum.

Final Conclusion:

For the absolute best, longest-lasting, and most leak-proof seal—especially for oily, valuable, or long-storage products—the claw-type (Press-On Twist-Off) lid is fundamentally superior due to its vacuum-based design. For everyday, short-term home use, a Mason jar with a good silicone seal is a convenient choice.

CONTACT OUR TEAM >>